Industries / Insurance agencies and brokers
Wanna OS for insurance agencies and brokers
Written by Wanna AI. Checked on 21 Nov 2026. Wanna is our product and is in the top 5; it is scored by the same rule as the others, and the rule is below. This page is not legal or compliance advice.
Short answer. Policyholders want their agent involved, yet only 21% get proactive contact, and only 20% of auto shoppers who own a home were offered a home quote. Independent agencies keep about 84% of clients a year, and most new business still comes by referral. The tools below can answer calls, qualify leads and draft the renewal, cross-sell and partner letters a small agency never has time to write. Most agency software hides its prices, which is why few tools score well.
The top 5 AI tools for insurance agencies, scored
| Tool | Rank | Score | Best for | Price, read 21 Nov 2026 | Honest minus |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Smith.ai | 1 | 9/10 | Calls the office cannot take: AI-first answering with people as backup, screening and qualifying leads and booking meetings | Receptionist plans from 300 dollars a month for 30 calls, 11.50 per extra call | Per-call price adds up quickly at agency call volumes |
| Wanna | 2 | 9/10 | Correspondence and marketing done for the agency: renewal check-ins, cross-sell letters, letters to referral partners, posts and ads; with your Gmail connected, each new client letter becomes a task with a drafted reply | Plans from 10 dollars a month (pricing), paid in credits | Not an agency management system or rater; a free trial and the cancellation terms are not shown on its pages |
| Agency Revolution Fuse | 3 | 4/10 | Renewal reminders, birthday emails and cross-sell messages sent from your agency management data | From 249 dollars a month plus a 500-dollar setup; done-for-you marketing from 649 | Its AI features are listed but not described; contract terms not shown |
| Open GI | 4 | 2/10 | UK brokers: policy administration with a machine-learning score of how likely a risk is to claim | Not shown | No price on its pages |
| Sonant AI | 5 | 2/10 | An AI receptionist for property and casualty agencies that verifies callers and handles routine requests inside your agency system | Quoted after a demo | No price, trial or contract terms on its pages |
Just outside the five: EZLynx (1/10), the comparative rater for 330+ carriers whose embedded AI cuts data entry, price not shown. Also common, but with no AI shown on their own pages, so not scored: HawkSoft (99 dollars per user a month), Momentum AMS (from 119 a month) and AgencyZoom (99 to 349 a month, month-to-month).
How we scored
Five questions, 0 to 2 points each, answered only from each vendor's own pages on 21 Nov 2026. We read pages; we did not run the tools.
- Does the AI do the work itself? 2 if the vendor's page says the AI answers, qualifies, drafts or resolves; 1 if it assists, predicts or is not described; 0 if no AI is shown.
- Is the price on its own page? 2 for full prices, 1 for "from" prices, 0 for quote only.
- Can you leave easily? 2 if month-to-month or no long-term contract is stated, 1 if monthly billing is offered but the terms are not, 0 if not shown.
- Can you set it up without a tech person? 2 if it is done for you, self-serve or has no setup fee, 1 if it needs a paid setup or onboarding, 0 if not shown.
- Does it fit a small agency's budget? 2 for an entry price up to 100 dollars a month, 1 up to 300, 0 above 300 or by quote.
These come from what agents say when they choose (below): fit to the agency's size and lines, a rater connected to its carriers, carrier downloads, support, and the cost of leaving. Ties are listed alphabetically. Every score is checked again every 30 days.
The agency market in numbers
| Measure | United States | United Kingdom |
|---|---|---|
| Agencies | 160,547 agency and brokerage locations with 995,254 employees (2024); about 37,000 independent property and casualty agencies, down from 39,000 in 2024, with 9.9 staff on average | 3,800 broker businesses on 4,995 sites, 2,160 of them with 0 to 4 staff (March 2026) |
| Revenue and premium | 191.1 billion dollars of agency and brokerage revenue (2022); independent agencies place 62% of 1.1 trillion dollars of property and casualty premium (87.7% of commercial lines, 39.5% of personal) | Brokers wrote 105.5 billion pounds of premium and arrange 94% of commercial lines (2024) |
| Commission | 11.5% on average (2024): private auto 8%, homeowners 12.4% | Not measured recently in what we read |
| Margin | 23.2% to 30.7% pro forma profit at best-practice agencies (2026) | Regulation costs 5.2% of premiums, 3.3% of them borne by brokers |
| Marketing | 20,600 dollars a year on average, up from 14,300 in 2024 | Not measured in what we read |
| Using AI | 46% of independent agencies use AI in some form, 14% have formally rolled out a tool; users save about 4 hours a week | Surveys disagree: 80% of 207 broking firms had not implemented AI in one; 70% said they use generative AI in another, with a wider definition |
How people buy insurance now
- US commercial clients: agents name referrals (92%) and personal connections (61%) as their top sources; websites, social media and ads bring 16% of new opportunities (2022).
- US auto shoppers (12,437 people, 2026): 53% shopped, getting 3.5 quotes on average, and 48% of new auto policies were bought digitally.
- US small businesses: 60% buy business insurance without an agent, in a survey by a digital insurer.
- UK households: 64% of motor policyholders bought or arranged through a price comparison site; 61% switched provider in three years; 94% shopped around.
- UK businesses: 79% of SMEs find a broker's advice useful.
What it means for an agency: personal lines move to screens and comparison sites, while commercial clients and the households who want advice still choose a person. The agency that keeps in touch keeps the client.
What decides who keeps the client
- Contact. Nearly 90% of policyholders want their agent involved in managing their policies, but only 21% get proactive outreach, and 35% expect an answer within an hour.
- Cross-sell. 45% of active auto shoppers own a homeowners policy, but only 20% were offered a home quote.
- Retention. Independent agencies keep about 84% of clients; only 18% raised retention by 5 points or more last year.
- Carriers. The average agency works with 17 carriers, and juggling their portals is the top technology complaint.
- People. Finding strong job candidates is the top challenge for 45% of agencies.
- Consolidation. 695 US agency deals were done in 2025 and 99 in the UK; one US agency in three expects an ownership change within five years.
Who the big players are
| United States, 2025 US revenue | United Kingdom |
|---|---|
| Marsh: 13.1 billion dollars | Howden: 3.6 billion pounds of revenue (2025) |
| Gallagher: 8.8 billion | The Ardonagh Group: income up 20.4% in 2025 |
| Aon: 8.2 billion | Gallagher UK: in the top band of UK general insurance revenue |
| Alliant: 5.7 billion | Compare the Market: 602 million pounds of revenue, 8.5 million customers |
| Brown & Brown: 4.9 billion | MoneySuperMarket: 232.5 million pounds of insurance revenue |
Big brokers and comparison sites win on scale and price screens. An independent agency wins on what they cannot copy: a named agent who calls before the renewal, advice on what the policy really covers, and local partners who send clients.
The rules that shape agency marketing
- US, NAIC Model 880 (adopted in some form by the states): no misrepresenting a policy's benefits, terms or premium, and no misleading advertising in any medium; gifts tied to marketing are limited (the model suggests the lesser of 5% of premium or 250 dollars; check your state).
- US, licence numbers: California requires the licence number on business cards, written quotes, print ads and emails.
- US, TCPA: autodialled or prerecorded marketing calls and texts to mobiles need prior written consent; no telemarketing before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m.; respect the Do Not Call registry.
- UK, FCA ICOBS 2.2: every promotion must be clear, fair and not misleading; "cheapest" or "save" claims must match what most customers actually get.
- UK, Consumer Duty: good outcomes for retail customers across marketing, sale and support.
- UK, ICOBS 6B: a renewal price may not be higher than the equivalent new-customer price through the same channel.
- UK, PECR: marketing emails and texts to individuals need consent or the soft opt-in.
What owners look for when they choose
From agents' own discussions and a survey of agents:
- A fit to the agency's size and its mix of personal and commercial lines.
- A rater actually connected to the carriers you write, and carrier downloads that work.
- The cost of leaving later, and how support is priced.
- Daily usability, good proposals and a vendor roadmap you can trust.
- Ease of use and speed of quoting.
What Wanna OS runs for an insurance agency
Wanna is not an agency management system, a rater or a phone line. It is the correspondence and marketing a small agency never finds time for.
- Letters to clients: drafts renewal check-ins and cross-sell letters, such as a home quote for an auto client, for your OK; with your Gmail connected, each new client letter becomes a task within minutes with a drafted reply.
- Referral partners: can find estate agents, mortgage brokers, car dealers and accountants near you, and drafts the letters to them.
- Content: posts and short articles that explain cover in plain words, without "cheapest" or price claims you cannot back.
- Visibility in AI answers: keeps the agency described where search engines and AI tools read, so it can be named when someone asks for an agent nearby.
- Your OK first: ads always wait for your OK, while posts wait unless you choose Autopilot; letters go out only after you turn sending on (Trust). Wanna makes no calls; add your licence number to letters where your state requires it.
Locally
- United States: independent agencies place most commercial business, personal auto moves online, and rules on ads, gifts, licence numbers and calls are set state by state and by the TCPA.
- United Kingdom: comparison sites dominate home and motor, brokers arrange almost all commercial lines, and FCA pricing and promotion rules are strict.
What this page does not replace
It does not replace your own trial of each tool, your carriers' and regulator's rules, your state's insurance department guidance, or legal advice.
FAQ
What is the best AI for a small insurance agency? By our scoring on 21 Nov 2026, Smith.ai and Wanna score 9 out of 10, Agency Revolution Fuse 4, Open GI and Sonant AI 2. Pick by the job: Smith.ai for calls, Wanna for correspondence and marketing, Fuse for automated renewal emails, Open GI for UK broking, Sonant for an agency phone line.
Why do insurance agency tools score low? Most agency software does not publish prices or contract terms, so it cannot earn points for them; several also show no AI on their own pages.
How do insurance agencies get new clients? Agents name referrals (92%) and personal connections (61%) as their top sources of new commercial clients; online channels bring about 16% of new opportunities.
How many insurance agencies are there? About 37,000 independent property and casualty agencies in the US in 2026, and 3,800 broker businesses in the UK.
What is the client retention rate of an agency? About 84% on average for US independent agencies in 2026.
Can AI write my renewal and cross-sell letters? Wanna drafts them for your OK, and Fuse sends automated renewal and cross-sell emails from your agency data. Keep claims and prices within NAIC, state and FCA rules.
Paste your link and see the plan Wanna would make for your agency.